Recent happenings reveal a rise in neo-paganism and religious syncretism among Christians in Igboland. This is evident in the sudden return of Igbo Christians, especially young people, to different forms of African Traditional Religion. While some claim to do this simply because it is their cultural heritage, many do it in a quest for solutions to different problems. This work begins with a clarification of terms and an exposition of neo-paganism and religious syncretism in Igboland. It identifies such causes as shallow evangelization, incomplete conversion, inadequate catechesis, conflict between faith and culture and the quest for solutions. It highlights the theological, pastoral and psycho-social implications for the Church. Finally, it recommends intensified theological education, the culture of witness, integral Christian formation, special attention to the youths, inculturation and the digitalization of the Christian message. If these ills of neo-paganism and religious syncretism in Igboland are to be addressed, immediate action must be taken by the Church.